Gentoo Qt Team March 2012 meeting

Date: 25 March 2012
Time: 1300 UTC
Place: #gentoo-meetings @freenode

The full meeting log can be found here. Meeting summary is written by kensington.

1) Roll call
hwoarang, johu, pesa, tampakrap, wired, yngwin

2) Qt 5
* pesa is working on it locally, and started a new eclass from scratch. He’ll
push to the overlay once upstream settles down, probably after a packaged alpha
is released (note that binary compatibility is not guaranteed with the final

* Upstream is planning split tarballs for later releases, and we’re going to
follow that except for qtbase, which will probably be split the same as in Qt 4
– qt-{core,gui,sql,dbus}.

* Need to handle slotting of qmake. Any ebuild calling qmake directly should be
fixed to use eqmake{4,5}. Autotools etc. is sometimes used to detect qmake which
shouldn’t be broken. qmake{4,5} will probably suffice, but we should watch
upstreams / other distros to see what they do, and revisit the issue later.

3) qt4.eclass deprecation
* wired maintains a list of ebuilds still using the class: and there are about 60 left
in the tree

* We should try to clear out the ebuilds in testing first. Since there is a
repoman warning, we can start filing bugs / stable requests to get them fixed.

4) Unmaintained/obsolete packages
* qgtkstyle – this is duplicated in qt-gui[gtkstyle]. hwoarang will lastrite it
so it can be treecleaned.

* qvfb – it is stuck at 4.6.3 and nothing in the tree uses it, so we don’t care
about it. Since is has no bugs there’s no need to remove it, so hwoarang will
set it to maintainer-needed.

5) Get eclass translation handling into official tree
* The code in the overlay covers enough cases to make it worth merging it to the
tree. pesa will submit the code to the dev mailing list for review before it it
is merged into qt4-r2.

* With regards to eclass development in the future, we want to change the
workflow to match how the KDE herd does it. That is, replace qt4-edge with
qt4-r2 and use the overlay as a staging area.

6) Open bugs
* Bug #398885 – x11-libs/qt-assistant-4.7.4 qdoc3 loops forever on arm & ppc
This is blocking 4.7.4 stabilising on arm and is therefore a high priority. ppc
already stabilised, so the bug might only affect certain machines. We should
retry the out-of-portage build (see comment #1) and investigate further.

* Bug #367583 – x11-libs/qt-dbus-4.7.2 –
../../include/QtCore/../../src/corelib/arch/qatomic_generic.h:197: error:
invalid conversion from ‘const void*’ to ‘void*’
We have two candidate patches to choose from – one eclass, one code. pesa will
try to get an opinion from upstream about the code patch.

* Bug #401557 – x11-libs/qt-core-4.8 –
hint: qt-4.8 : add a ewarn to recompile cairo *after* qt-4.8
wired will add a warning to either qt-core or qt-gui.

* Bug #398497 – /usr/include/qt4/Gentoo/gentoo-qconfig.h should be under package
manager control
This bug is probably the result of an oversight by the original eclass authors,
and we agree that the file should indeed be under package manager control.

* Bug #372721 – [qt overlay] x11-libs/libmeegotouch-9999 doesn’t compile
Nobody cares about this package, so pesa will remove it from the overlay and
mark it WONTFIX.

* Bug #388551 – x11-libs/qt-gui should depend on gnome-base/libgnomeui-2 when
USE=”gtkstyle” is enabled
During the last meeting we decided to add an elog, but nobody actually did it.

* Bug #285743 – “webkit” USE flag standardization
We decided to do this 2 years ago, but never got around to it. The flag mostly
has two meanings: (1) add support for HTML rendering and (2) build bindings for
WebKit. wired will propose (1) to the dev mailing list: “Enable support for the
WebKit html rendering engine”, and (2) can be a local flag description.

* Bug #404283 – media-gfx/imagemagick – convert: unable to close module `SVG’:
/usr/lib64/qt4/ undefined symbol:
_ZN11QMetaObject11removeGuardEPP7QObject @
wired will request more information from the reporter.

Gentoo KDE Team March 2012 meeting

Date: 22 March 2012
Time: 2000 UTC
Place: #gentoo-meetings @freenode

The full meeting log can be found here. Meeting summary is written by dastergon.

1) Roll call

alexxy, dilfridge, johu, mschiff, scarabeus, tampakrap

2) Electing a new team leader


Accepted: dilfridge, johu
Refused: tampakrap, scarabeus

johu -> dilfridge
dilfridge -> johu
tampakrap -> dilfridge
alexxy -> dilfridge
mschiff -> dilfridge
scarabeus -> dilfridge
dilfridge:5 – johu:1
dilfridge is the new KDE team leader with the majority of votes.

3) Dropping RPATH from installed binaries

Add a RPATH entry for every library dir that is not in the system library
directories in ld.conf are not automatically considered as system library
dirs, but only some static list of dirs.
Everyone agreed on RPATH removal. We will introduce a patch with KDE SC 4.8.2
to remove the RPATH and move it to the main tree.

4) Bugs

* Remove hard dep on media-libs/phonon from kde-base/kdelibs
Upstream says “technically you can replace phonon with qt-phonon, but that’s
just stupid because you lose functionality”. Another argument against it, is
that qt-phonon will be removed with qt5. We wont fix the bug and keep phonon as
hard dep. johu will take care of the bug after meeting summary is available.

* Eclass problem with handbook without LINGUAS.
The handbook eclass code is pretty confusing for all in meeting present
members. It was written by reavertm. We decided that we will mail reveartm to
fix handbook eclass code, because he has the most knowledge in it. dilfridge
will take care of contacting him, it’s his first lead task.

* Revise the change “semantic-desktop? -> semantic-desktop=”.
Some packages rely on semantic-desktop capabilities in other ones. tampakrap
is volunteers to take care of the bug.

5) Open floor

* KDE 4.8 stabilization
KWin does not build anymore without opengl support. kde-base/kmail-4.8.1
crashes, but upstream patch can be backported. KDE SC 4.8.1 has tons of
bugfixes, compared to to 4.8.0. The majority votes for KDE 4.8.1 as stable
candidate. johu will prepare stabilization.

* Test failures
creffett brought up dbus-related test failures. johu recommended to get
virtual-dbus eclass running. dilfridge suggested if one or two test fails
or restrict. The problems with virtual-dbus is that you can’t run bash
commands in it’s environment. creffett will be responsible for this.

* New members
Welcome to three new members of the project: creffett, kensington and
dastergon. They are in the process to become gentoo developer and mentored by
tampakrap. creffett and kensington have already open ‘new developer’ bug.
dastergon doesn’t have an open bug yet.

* Comeback
scarabeus re-joined KDE herd. Welcome back!!!

* Reduced work time
mschiff mentioned that he will not have much time for the KDE herd due to
real life priorities, he will be back in may. tampakrap will spent most of his
time for gentoo infra team.

Meeting bits

Yesterday (2012/01/16 20:00 UTC) we had the first Gentoo KDE team meeting this year. The meeting happened in #gentoo-meetings on freenode.

  • Participants: alexxy, dilfridge, jmbsvicetto, johu, mschiff, tampakrap, Thev00d00
  • Agenda
  • Log
  • Lead election is delayed, because 12 months not over
  • We keep kdepim-4.4 in tree as long as it works and provide kdepim-l10n package
  • Kdeenablefinal build feature will be removed today
  • Phonon xine backend will be removed in 15 days
  • We expect no big issues with Qt 4.8,  only kdenlive is not building at the moment
  • eselect boost vs. latest boost is not a Gentoo KDE scope only issue, we will move the discussion to the gentoo-dev mailing list
  • … read log 😛 or wait for the full summary by tampakrap
  • My netbook had a kernel panic while the meeting  :-/
After the meeting i joined the Gentoo Qt team.